The biggest lie about: The Trojan Horse
The old Trojan Horse trick is one of the most legendary
deceits of all time, so there's no doubt that this story is going be chock full
of lies. Not only is Odysseus’ sneaky plan totally deceptive,
the plan also requires Simon to tell a whole string of lies to get the Trojans
to drag the giant horse into their city. So, the real question becomes this:
just how dishonourable is it of the Greeks to use this tactic? You could see
them as low down scoundrels, or you could see them as just being smarter than
their enemies.
But was it just a myth? Probably,
says Oxford University classicist Dr Armand D'Angour: 'Archaeological evidence
shows that Troy was indeed burned down; but the wooden horse is an imaginative
fable, perhaps inspired by the way ancient siege-engines were clothed with damp
horse-hides to stop them being set alight.'
There
is even doubt about the existence of the man said to have written the Odyssey,
Homer, who is considered to be the greatest of Greek epic poets. Dr D'Angour
explains: 'It's generally supposed that the great epics which go under Homer's
name, the Iliad and Odyssey,
were composed orally, without the aid of writing, some time in the 8th Century
BC, the fruit of a tradition of oral minstrelsy stretching back for centuries.
'While
the ancients had no doubt that Homer was a real bard who composed the
monumental epics, nothing certain is known about him. All we do know is that,
even if the poems were composed without writing and orally transmitted, at some
stage they were written down in Greek, because that is how they have survived.'
Dr
D'Angour explains the origins of another eight stories and myths in an article for BBC, which has been reached millions of people
as one of the most shared on the website over the last few days.
Dr
D'Angour is currently undertaking a two-year project to recover the sounds of
Greek music and to work out what significance these sounds have for some of the
most famous poems from Ancient Greece.
'Imagine
a situation in which all we had of five centuries of Western opera were the
libretti, and only a few fragments of the music,' he explains. 'Such a
situation is, more or less, that of students who engage with the poetry of
classical Greece, which covers around five centuries from 800 to 300 BC.
'The
poets who composed the Iliad and Odyssey, the love poems of archaic Lesbos, the
victory odes of the early fifth century BC, and the choral passages of Greek
tragedy and comedy — all composed the words to be sung and accompanied by
musical instruments.
Comments
Post a Comment